Arrest made in Calhoun County murder cold case from 2003 - ABC 33/40 - Birmingham News, Weather, Sports

Arrest made in Calhoun County murder cold case from 2003

Posted: Updated:
Randall Wayne Kirkpatrick (Photo: Dyer County Sheriff's Office) Randall Wayne Kirkpatrick (Photo: Dyer County Sheriff's Office)
CALHOUN COUNTY, Ala. - A Tennessee man faces murder charges more than a decade after his wife died in Piedmont.

Calhoun County Sheriff Larry Amerson announced Tuesday the arrest of 33-year-old Randall Wayne Kirkpatrick for the murder of Deborah Lynn Smith Kirkpatrick.  She was 22 at the time of her death in June 2003.

The initial report was of an apparent suicide.  Amerson said an investigation by the Piedmont Police Department and Department of Forensic Sciences concluded that it was an undetermined cause of death.

Ann Parris, Deborah Kirkpatrick's sister, said she knew right away that it was not suicide.

"It just felt like it was in a nightmare.  It didn't seem real.  It still doesn't," Parris said.

"I knew my sister, and she wasn't suicidal."

She said her sister was preparing to leave her husband because of negative behavior.  Parris said Kirkpatrick did not want the couple's infant son to be in that environment.

Randall Kirkpatrick moved to Tennessee with the young boy right after his wife's death.  Parris said she kept in touch with her nephew on Facebook in recent years, but after investigators reopened the cold case, she said Kirkpatrick blocked family members from seeing the child's Facebook page and also changed phone numbers.

"He didn't just kill her.  In a way, he literally killed my family.  It destroyed my family.  A lot of them has took the wrong paths since then," Parris said Tuesday.

She said she knew a day would come when investigators would find proof this was not a suicide.  Parris said she continued to fight for years by ringing phones of the hook and knocking on doors.

Sheriff Amerson said the Calhoun County cold case unit and the Calhoun-Cleburne District Attorney's office reviewed information last year that led them to reopen and reanalyze the case.

"After many months of hard work and interviewing witnesses ... and attempting to interview the husband, evidence was developed that this case was not in fact a suicide but was in fact a homicide," Amerson said.

The Center for Applied Forensic Science at Jacksonville State University helped investigators reconstruct the room of Deborah Kirkpatrick's home where police found her body.

District attorney Brian McVeigh said there were questions about the crime scene from the very beginning.  He said the story put forward by Randall Kirkpatrick did not match all of the forensic evidence in the home.  Investigators said Kirkpatrick's actions were not consistent with the expected response of a grieving spouse.

"Once they reopened the case and began interviewing evidence, they found some additional evidence that assisted in providing a potential motive," McVeigh said.

"If it wasn't a suicide, then there was only one other person in that room who could have done it, and that led us down the path toward grand jury."

A Calhoun County grand jury indicted Randall Kirkpatrick in June for murdering his wife 11 years earlier.  Deputies in Dyer County, Tennessee, took Kirkpatrick into custody Friday for extradition back to Alabama.

Amerson said this is the 13th murder solved by Calhoun County cold case unit since its creation in 2000.

"Cases like these allow a murderer to walk free among us," Amerson said.

"It is our duty and responsibility, whenever we possibly can, to bring closure to that case.  Closure to the family, and to bring justice for the victims who can no longer speak for themselves."

Ann Parris said she is ecstatic about the arrest, but she does not expect to get closure from it.

"I do expect justice," she said.

"I think maybe now it will start healing some of those broken pieces.  I don't think it will ever be completely healed."

Investigators said Randall Kirkpatrick has not answered any of their questions despite numerous requests for interviews during recent months.

  • Central Alabama NewsMore>>

  • Judge delays decision on abortion law

    Judge delays decision on abortion law

    Thursday, July 31 2014 1:54 PM EDT2014-07-31 17:54:07 GMT
    A federal judge is delaying his decision on an Alabama law that could close some abortion clinics. U.S. District Judge Myron Thompson told attorneys in June that he hoped to rule by the end of July. But Thompson notified attorneys Thursday that he needs extra time and will have a ruling by Monday. Thompson said he needs time to consider a federal appeals court ruling Tuesday that blocked a similar Mississippi law. Alabama's law requires doctors at abortion clinics to have approval to admit pa...More >>
    A federal judge is delaying his decision on an Alabama law that could close some abortion clinics. U.S. District Judge Myron Thompson told attorneys in June that he hoped to rule by the end of July. But Thompson notified attorneys Thursday that he needs extra time and will have a ruling by Monday. Thompson said he needs time to consider a federal appeals court ruling Tuesday that blocked a similar Mississippi law. Alabama's law requires doctors at abortion clinics to have approval to admit pa...More >>
  • Rainbow City woman, 56, killed in accident on I-59 near Argo Wednesday night

    Rainbow City woman, 56, killed in accident on I-59 near Argo Wednesday night

    Thursday, July 31 2014 11:48 AM EDT2014-07-31 15:48:12 GMT
    A Rainbow City woman was killed and her husband was injured Wednesday in a single-vehicle crash on Interstate 59 near Argo, Alabama State Troopers said.More >>
    A Rainbow City woman was killed and her husband was injured Wednesday in a single-vehicle crash on Interstate 59 near Argo, Alabama State Troopers said.More >>
  • 3 West Chilton County Volunteer Fire Department officials arrested on theft charges

    3 West Chilton County Volunteer Fire Department officials arrested on theft charges

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 6:07 PM EDT2014-07-30 22:07:24 GMT
    A continuing investigation into the theft of Fire Department funds in central Alabama has led to the arrest of three West Chilton County Volunteer Fire Department officials, the state fire marshal's office announced today.More >>
    A continuing investigation into the theft of Fire Department funds in central Alabama has led to the arrest of three West Chilton County Volunteer Fire Department officials, the state fire marshal's office announced today.
    More >>
  • Birmingham Area NewsMore>>

  • Small plane crash in Helena sends 4 to hospital with serious injuries

    Small plane crash in Helena sends 4 to hospital with serious injuries

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:29 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:29:23 GMT
    Authorities are investigating a small plane crash in Helena Thursday afternoon, a fire spokesman said.More >>
    Authorities are investigating a small plane crash in Helena Thursday afternoon, a fire spokesman said.More >>
  • Car tag renewal locations opening Monday

    Car tag renewal locations opening Monday

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:29 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:29:21 GMT
    Being able to renew a car tag in Hoover begins Monday. And, it's available for any resident of Jefferson County. The temporary location for this new car tag renewal service will be at Hoover Metropolitan Stadium. But, a permanent site is still in the works.The city is looking for space in Hoover. Hoover city councilman, John Lyda, says the finishing touches on the tag renewal project are taking place at the Hoover Met. "The county has been overseeing the project at the Met, to get the techno...More >>
    Being able to renew a car tag in Hoover begins Monday. And, it's available for any resident of Jefferson County. The temporary location for this new car tag renewal service will be at Hoover Metropolitan Stadium. But, a permanent site is still in the works.The city is looking for space in Hoover. Hoover city councilman, John Lyda, says the finishing touches on the tag renewal project are taking place at the Hoover Met. "The county has been overseeing the project at the Met, to get the techno...More >>
  • Embattled Homewood hotel forced to close, guests left looking for new accommodations

    Embattled Homewood hotel forced to close, guests left looking for new accommodations

    Thursday, July 31 2014 5:00 PM EDT2014-07-31 21:00:10 GMT
    Guests at America's Best Inn Suites packed up and left Thursday. The Homewood hotel lost its business license and an extension to keep it running was denied.More >>
    Guests at America's Best Inn Suites packed up and left Thursday. The Homewood hotel lost its business license and an extension to keep it running was denied.
    More >>
Most Popular
Stories
Videos
loading...