Last BCS debate is first College Football Playoff debate - ABC 33/40 - Birmingham News, Weather, Sports

Last BCS debate is first College Football Playoff debate

Posted: Updated:

The last big BCS debate is in a way the first big College Football Playoff debate.

In this 16th and final season of the Bowl Championship Series, all the talk lately has been about strength of schedule — or the lack thereof for No. 1 Florida State and No. 2 Ohio State in comparison to the teams playing for the Southeastern Conference championship.

The conference commissioners who created the four-team playoff that replaces the BCS next year have gone out of their way to say they want the selection committee that picks those four teams to put a premium on schedule strength.

So instead of simply debating No. 3 Auburn or Ohio State, let's play this forward and ask the question: What if we had to pick four teams this season?

Let's assume the favorites win out Saturday. Here are the teams that would be up for debate:

Florida State (ACC champion)

Ohio State (Big Ten champion)

Auburn (SEC champion)

Oklahoma State (Big 12 champion)

Arizona State (Pac-12 champion)

Alabama

Baylor

Others that would be worthy of a mention: South Carolina, Oregon, Michigan State and Missouri, and unbeaten Northern Illinois at least has its resume on the table.

The BCS standings would solve this riddle by picking Florida State, Ohio State and Auburn. Alabama and Oklahoma State would be fighting for that last spot, with the Tide having the inside track.

But the BCS standings are driven by poll voters who generally stack teams in order of record, with the exception of teams such as NIU from BCS non-automatic qualifying conferences.

In a world where strength of schedule is supposed to be at the forefront, how could the Pac-12 champion be left out?

The Sagarin computer ratings currently have No. 11 Arizona State's schedule as the fourth toughest in the country before playing No. 7 Stanford on Saturday night at home for the Pac-12 title.

No. 4 Alabama's schedule is 48th toughest in Division I. Oklahoma State's is 43rd.

ESPN also has a strength of schedule metric that has Arizona State's schedule strength at No. 3 in FBS. Alabama's is 54th. Oklahoma State's 48th.

For perspective, the difference between Arizona State's schedule ranking and those of Alabama and Oklahoma State in both those metrics is greater than the difference between Auburn's and either Florida State's or Ohio State's.

Note to SEC schools: Replacing a patsy on your schedule with another conference game — the way the Pac-12 does — goes a long way toward beefing up your SOS. Especially when your conference is as good as the Pac-12 has been this season, grading out as no worse than a close second to the SEC.

Of course, it's not just about who you play but how you play, and there would be many other factors to weigh. But it'd be hard to argue against the champion of the second-toughest conference that played clearly the toughest schedule. It gets even tougher if Stanford is the Pac-12 champ, because then you can eliminate the whole Wisconsin-game fiasco as it relates to Arizona State.

That brings us back to this season and the current debate. If a one-loss team deserves to trump an undefeated team because of schedule, then why not a two-loss team over a one-loss team for the same reason?

The picks:

MAIN EVENT

No. 2 Ohio State (minus 5½) vs. No. 10 Michigan State, Big Ten championship in Indianapolis

A decisive win by the Buckeyes would end the drama — or a loss ... MICHIGAN STATE 31-28.

MARQUEE MATCHUPS

No. 1 Florida State (minus 29) vs. No. 20 Duke, ACC championship at Charlotte, N.C.

If Blue Devils can pull this off, forget coach of the year, David Cutcliffe gets coach of the decade ... FLORIDA STATE 48-14.

No. 3 Auburn (minus 2) vs. No. 5 Missouri, SEC championship at Atlanta

Just admit it. It's Gus Malzahn's world ... AUBURN 35-28.

No. 7 Stanford (plus 3) at No. 11 Arizona State, Pac-12 championship

Sun Devils can earn first Rose Bowl bid since 1996 season ... ARIZONA STATE 31-27

No. 18 Oklahoma (plus 10) at No. 6 Oklahoma State

Sooners have won nine of 10 in Bedlam, but not the last one in Stillwater ... OKLAHOMA STATE 28-20.

No. 23 Texas (plus 14) at No. 9 Baylor

If Oklahoma State loses, winner here gets Big 12 title ... BAYLOR 42-21.

No. 19 Louisville (minus 3½) at Cincinnati, Thursday

Last Keg of Nails rivalry game for the foreseeable future ... LOUISVILLE 35-33.

No. 16 Northern Illinois (minus 3) vs. Bowling Green, MAC championship at Detroit, Friday

BCS bid on the line for Huskies, and Heisman Trophy ceremony invitation for Jordan Lynch ... NORTHERN ILLINOIS 28-27.

No. 15 UCF (off) at SMU

Mustangs might be without QB Garrett Gilbert (knee) ... UCF 45-24.

BEST BET

Utah State (plus 3½) at No. 24 Fresno State, MWC championship

Last chance for Derek Carr to make a Heisman push ... FRESNO STATE 38-31.

UPSET SPECIAL

Marshall (minus 5) at Rice, Conference USA championship

Winner goes to Liberty Bowl; expect plenty of points ... RICE 42-35.

Last week: Record straight: 12-4; vs. points 6-10.

Season: 216-46; 117-117-3.

Best bet: 9-4-1.

Upset special: 5-5.

___

Follow Ralph D. Russo at www.Twitter.com/ralphDrussoAP

  • UAB SportsMore>>

  • Fans ready for start of football season

    Fans ready for start of football season

    Thursday, August 28 2014 7:45 AM EDT2014-08-28 11:45:46 GMT
    For some people, tonight is just as exciting as Christmas Eve! Thursday kicks off the college football season. Many fans have been counting down the days.More >>
    For some people, tonight is just as exciting as Christmas Eve! Thursday kicks off the college football season. Many fans have been counting down the days.
    More >>
  • UAB names Cody Clements starting quarterback vs Troy

    UAB names Cody Clements starting quarterback vs Troy

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 3:13 PM EDT2014-08-26 19:13:29 GMT
    UAB will open the season with Cody Clements at quarterback. Clements, a junior college transfer from Cerritos College in California, beat out redshirt freshman Jeremiah Briscoe for the starting job.More >>
    UAB will open the season with Cody Clements at quarterback. Clements, a junior college transfer from Cerritos College in California, beat out redshirt freshman Jeremiah Briscoe for the starting job.More >>
  • UAB guard Chad Frazier granted his release from basketball program

    UAB guard Chad Frazier granted his release from basketball program

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 7:12 PM EDT2014-07-29 23:12:02 GMT
    The leading scorer on the UAB basketball team is leaving the program. Guard Chad Frazier was granted his release and will not return."Chad Frazier has been granted his release from our program," head coach Jerod Haase said in a statement. "We appreciate his contributions to our program and wish him the best." Frazier, a first team All-Conference USA selection, was arrested last month and charged with third degree domestic violence. The case was later dismissed.Frazier played one season at UAB...More >>
    The leading scorer on the UAB basketball team is leaving the program. Guard Chad Frazier was granted his release and will not return."Chad Frazier has been granted his release from our program," head coach Jerod Haase said in a statement. "We appreciate his contributions to our program and wish him the best." Frazier, a first team All-Conference USA selection, was arrested last month and charged with third degree domestic violence. The case was later dismissed.Frazier played one season at UAB...More >>
  • All other Local CollegesMore>>

  • Samford coach Pat Sullivan will not travel with team to TCU

    Samford coach Pat Sullivan will not travel with team to TCU

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 2:59 PM EDT2014-08-27 18:59:15 GMT
    Samford football coach Pat Sullivan will miss Saturday's season opener against TCU. The school announced that Sullivan has been advised against traveling by doctors while he recovers from offseason surgery."Unfortunately I will not be able to make the trip with my Samford team this weekend for our game against TCU," Sullivan said in a statement released through the school. "My doctors have advised me not to travel at this time due to a complication from a surgery earlier this year. We have an...More >>
    Samford football coach Pat Sullivan will miss Saturday's season opener against TCU. The school announced that Sullivan has been advised against traveling by doctors while he recovers from offseason surgery."Unfortunately I will not be able to make the trip with my Samford team this weekend for our game against TCU," Sullivan said in a statement released through the school. "My doctors have advised me not to travel at this time due to a complication from a surgery earlier this year. We have an...More >>
  • No. 8 Michigan State readies defense for opener against JSU

    No. 8 Michigan State readies defense for opener against JSU

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 7:54 PM EDT2014-08-26 23:54:33 GMT
    Mark Dantonio cares more about how Michigan State plays than how many plays Jacksonville State can run with its fast-tempo offense in Friday's season opener for both teams.More >>
    Mark Dantonio cares more about how Michigan State plays than how many plays Jacksonville State can run with its fast-tempo offense in Friday's season opener for both teams.
    More >>
  • TCU to play both QBs in opener against Samford

    TCU to play both QBs in opener against Samford

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 7:45 PM EDT2014-08-26 23:45:15 GMT
    Trevone Boykin is in the same position he was last year with TCU, again part of the unanswered question of who will be the starting quarterback only days before the season opener against Samford.More >>
    Trevone Boykin is in the same position he was last year with TCU, again part of the unanswered question of who will be the starting quarterback only days before the season opener against Samford.
    More >>
  • Latest StoriesMore>>

  • Tony Stewart back at the track, looking to heal

    Tony Stewart back at the track, looking to heal

    Saturday, August 30 2014 12:20 AM EDT2014-08-30 04:20:07 GMT
    Tony Stewart should be back in his comfort zone at a NASCAR track, ready for racing.More >>
    Tony Stewart took his seat on the podium - unshaven, his eyes glassy - and unfolded a sheet of paper. His voice quivered as he read, pausing to maintain his composure as he described the death of a driver he hit as "one of...More >>
  • Fire danger rises for Labor Day weekend

    Fire danger rises for Labor Day weekend

    Friday, August 29 2014 11:59 PM EDT2014-08-30 03:59:40 GMT
    Our recent dry weather has created the perfect conditions for fire danger. More >>
    Our recent dry weather has created the perfect conditions for fire danger. More >>
  • City Council to get update on education in Birmingham

    City Council to get update on education in Birmingham

    Friday, August 29 2014 8:55 PM EDT2014-08-30 00:55:45 GMT
    The Birmingham City Council is hosting a lunch meeting with the Birmingham Board of Education to discuss the current state and direction of the Birmingham City Schools. The meeting will be held Tuesday, September 2, 2014 from 12:45 p.m. to 2 p.m. at Regions Bank in the Executive Dining Room."We want to make sure that as a council we are engaged in all aspects of development for our city," Council President Jonathan Austin said. "It is very important that are continually updated on areas such ...More >>
    The Birmingham City Council is hosting a lunch meeting with the Birmingham Board of Education to discuss the current state and direction of the Birmingham City Schools. The meeting will be held Tuesday, September 2, 2014 from 12:45 p.m. to 2 p.m. at Regions Bank in the Executive Dining Room."We want to make sure that as a council we are engaged in all aspects of development for our city," Council President Jonathan Austin said. "It is very important that are continually updated on areas such ...More >>
  • Talladega parents allege school employee wrote racist Facebook posts

    Talladega parents allege school employee wrote racist Facebook posts

    Friday, August 29 2014 7:32 PM EDT2014-08-29 23:32:28 GMT
    Several parents and community members in Talladega are upset Friday over allegations of racial comments made from a school employee's Facebook page.More >>
    Several parents and community members in Talladega are upset Friday over allegations of racial comments made from a school employee's Facebook page.More >>
  • Fairview High School football stadium condemned; Game night plans change

    Fairview High School football stadium condemned; Game night plans change

    Friday, August 29 2014 6:36 PM EDT2014-08-29 22:36:45 GMT
    High school football continues into its second week of the season. Stadiums across Alabama will be filled with "Friday night lights.” But, one local stadium that's supposed to host a game will remain empty. The Fairview High School football stadium was condemned Thursday night.More >>
    High school football continues into its second week of the season. Stadiums across Alabama will be filled with "Friday night lights.” But, one local stadium that's supposed to host a game will remain empty. The Fairview High School football stadium was condemned Thursday night.
    More >>
  • Exclusive: Birmingham beats out Miami for DOT conference

    Exclusive: Birmingham beats out Miami for DOT conference

    Friday, August 29 2014 6:34 PM EDT2014-08-29 22:34:48 GMT
    ABC 33/40 has learned that the City of Birmingham beat out Miami for a DOT conference. A date for the conference has yet to be scheduled but hosting such an event gives the city an opportunity to solicit federal funding for transportation projects throughout the metro. Count on us to pass along any new information as soon as we get it.More >>
    ABC 33/40 has learned that the City of Birmingham beat out Miami for a DOT conference. A date for the conference has yet to be scheduled but hosting such an event gives the city an opportunity to solicit federal funding for transportation projects throughout the metro. Count on us to pass along any new information as soon as we get it.More >>
  • Hackleburg High School preps for first home game in three years

    Friday, August 29 2014 4:57 PM EDT2014-08-29 20:57:25 GMT
    Tonight is a homecoming three years in the making for Hackleburg High School. The team takes the field tonight in their new stadium, finally completed after an E-F five tornado destroyed it on April 27, 2011.It is sure to be a packed house at Ray Stadium as the Hackleburg panthers take on Marion County, tonight at 7:00 p.m. This is going to be an emotional night, not only for the school, but for the community as well. "This is going to be an emotional game, an emotional crowd. This field ho...More >>
    Tonight is a homecoming three years in the making for Hackleburg High School. The team takes the field tonight in their new stadium, finally completed after an E-F five tornado destroyed it on April 27, 2011.It is sure to be a packed house at Ray Stadium as the Hackleburg panthers take on Marion County, tonight at 7:00 p.m. This is going to be an emotional night, not only for the school, but for the community as well. "This is going to be an emotional game, an emotional crowd. This field ho...More >>
  • Caregiver charged with physically abusing nursing home patient in Hoover

    Caregiver charged with physically abusing nursing home patient in Hoover

    Friday, August 29 2014 4:49 PM EDT2014-08-29 20:49:12 GMT
    Taneka Kiera HopkinsTaneka Kiera Hopkins
    Hoover police have charged a former caregiver at South Haven Health and Rehab with physically abusing an 80 year old patient.More >>
    Hoover police have charged a former caregiver at South Haven Health and Rehab with physically abusing an 80 year old patient.More >>