Are educators taking zero tolerance too far? - ABC 33/40 - Birmingham News, Weather, Sports

Are educators taking zero tolerance too far?

Posted: Updated:

For almost 20 years, the zero tolerance federal law requires a minimum one-year expulsion of any student caught with a firearm on school property.

But the law gives local school administrators flexibility to fit circumstances. Many elementary school parents across the country say educators are taking everything too seriously, and it's time to get real.

There are instances where kindergartners are being suspended and forced into psychological evaluations because they used their finger as a gun on the playground, or had a bubble gun and threatened to blast bubbles.

Parents say that's just taking it too far. With recent tragedies, safety is a priority, but so is a child's innocence. Parents, and even a local school representative say common sense has got to come into play.

"I was pretending to play something with guns and they just made a big deal out of it," said eight-year-old Aragon Perez.

He certainly wasn't playing with a real gun, or even a toy gun. He was using his own hands and his imagination .  Still, his teacher told him to stop.

"So now I have to play something else," he said.

He wasn't suspended, but said his grandmother talked to him about why some teachers and students may not like his game.

Perez is part of a recent growing number of young children being corrected or even suspended for what parents say is simple child's play. Some suspensions have involved children as young as five years old.

"Are we talking about a terrorist threat by a four year old? I doubt it very seriously. I would contend that children are children and they play games," said one grandparent.

"I think that it's a little much to put on a child and suspend a child for reasons they're not even going to understand at that age," said another parent.

Some parents admit they didn't even mention the sandy hook shooting to their young children because the topic is too heavy, maybe even scary for them.

However, it is on the minds of many school officials whose job it is to ensure students' safety.

"We are certainly not going to put up with instances of bullying and threats and we do take threats very seriously," said Cindy Warner, spokesperson for Shelby County Schools.

Warner says it's also their job to use a common sense approach when it comes to infractions.

"Especially with younger students they sometimes are too young to appreciate the consequences of their action and we are generally going to use a more common sense approach," she said.

Warner says in cases with young students they try to involve the teachers and counselors in helping the student understand why their behavior may not be acceptable, instead of resorting to suspension.

  • Central Alabama NewsMore>>

  • Ex-band director at T.R. Miller High arrested on charges he had sex with students

    Ex-band director at T.R. Miller High arrested on charges he had sex with students

    Friday, August 22 2014 8:14 PM EDT2014-08-23 00:14:07 GMT
    A band director who just started a new job in Georgia appeared before a judge Friday on charges he had sex with several students at his former high school in Alabama.More >>
    A band director who just started a new job in Georgia appeared before a judge Friday on charges he had sex with several students at his former high school in Alabama.
    More >>
  • Civil rights protesters march at state capitol

    Civil rights protesters march at state capitol

    Friday, August 22 2014 7:22 PM EDT2014-08-22 23:22:20 GMT
    More than 20 people, including civil rights leaders and ministers, have marched around the state Capitol and Statehouse in the first day of a seven-day protest that stretches across the Southeast.Democratic state Sen. Hank Sanders of Selma says the marchers in Alabama are joining those in North Carolina, Mississippi, Georgia, South Carolina, Florida and Virginia to protest attacks on civil and human rights.The Alabama group marched around the Capitol and Statehouse in hot, humid weather Frida...More >>
    More than 20 people, including civil rights leaders and ministers, have marched around the state Capitol and Statehouse in the first day of a seven-day protest that stretches across the Southeast.Democratic state Sen. Hank Sanders of Selma says the marchers in Alabama are joining those in North Carolina, Mississippi, Georgia, South Carolina, Florida and Virginia to protest attacks on civil and human rights.The Alabama group marched around the Capitol and Statehouse in hot, humid weather Frida...More >>
  • Man charged in funeral home theft

    Man charged in funeral home theft

    Friday, August 22 2014 4:38 PM EDT2014-08-22 20:38:34 GMT
    Jerry William Duke charged with two counts of third degree burglaryJerry William Duke charged with two counts of third degree burglary
    A Shelby County man is in custody after police say he stole from the same funeral home twice. 32-year-old Jerry William Duke has been charged with two counts of third degree burglary. An undisclosed amount of money was taken from the funeral home in both instances.The two break ins occurred at the Midway Memory Gardens funeral home off of Alabama Highway 21 in Talladega County. Captain John McCoy with Talladega police confirm that Jerry Duke broke into the main building of the funeral home...More >>
    A Shelby County man is in custody after police say he stole from the same funeral home twice. 32-year-old Jerry William Duke has been charged with two counts of third degree burglary. An undisclosed amount of money was taken from the funeral home in both instances.The two break ins occurred at the Midway Memory Gardens funeral home off of Alabama Highway 21 in Talladega County. Captain John McCoy with Talladega police confirm that Jerry Duke broke into the main building of the funeral home...More >>
  • Birmingham Area NewsMore>>

  • Big turnout at bone marrow drive for Jefferson County deputy battling cancer

    Big turnout at bone marrow drive for Jefferson County deputy battling cancer

    Friday, August 22 2014 11:51 PM EDT2014-08-23 03:51:07 GMT
     The people who Sgt. Randy Nash spent his life serving - are now helping him in record numbers.More >>
     The people who Sgt. Randy Nash spent his life serving - are now helping him in record numbers.More >>
  • Friday Night Blitz coverage lineup for Week 1

    Friday Night Blitz coverage lineup for Week 1

    Friday, August 22 2014 11:25 PM EDT2014-08-23 03:25:25 GMT
    See the Game of the Week and other notable matchups to be covered on Friday Night Blitz...More >>
    See the Game of the Week and other notable matchups to be covered on Friday Night Blitz...
    More >>
  • Nearly 14,000 Alabamians waiting on state tax refunds

    Nearly 14,000 Alabamians waiting on state tax refunds

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:51 PM EDT2014-08-23 02:51:41 GMT
    Nearly 14,000 Alabamians are still waiting to get overdue tax refunds. Alabama's Revenue Commissioner blames the delay on a computer system designed to catch thieves.The delay is a bad thing for some taxpayers, but state leaders believe the delay is worth it.More >>
    Nearly 14,000 Alabamians are still waiting to get overdue tax refunds. Alabama's Revenue Commissioner blames the delay on a computer system designed to catch thieves.The delay is a bad thing for some taxpayers, but state leaders believe the delay is worth it.
    More >>
Most Popular
Stories
Videos
loading...